I was very excited to receive your Email request this morning, asking for my help in your battle against Hachette. Not since Carrie White got invited to the prom has a girl been more pleasantly shocked to be included. And you’re right; those big publisher types are just fuckers. I was a mid-list romance author for Pocket Books/Simon & Schuster all through the 2000s, and let me tell you—
Oh, right, sorry, you want to talk about your thing. No, yeah, of course; it’s totally fine. So anyway, okay, Hachette and its other big nasty “media conglomerate” friends have been being all hateful to you at Amazon about your e-books. I heard about the whole collusion thing – those bastards! You and the Supreme Court are so right; I don’t blame you one bit for being upset. I mean, I know in my heart that if you hadn’t already put every other bookselling outlet that could possibly affect the market at your level out of business, you and those peers you don’t have would never, ever sit down in a New York City restaurant to try to come to some sort of price fixing agreement. I can just see them all in there, smoking their big cigars, drinking their martinis – they probably pinched the pert derriere of the cigarette girl as she passed. Kudos to you and your lawyers for bringing them to justice. So now they’re coming after you one by one, starting with Hachette, and you’ve come to me for my help as a writer to fight back. I’m flattered; I really am.
But let’s talk about the pig’s blood before I put on the tiara. (Sadly, unlike Carrie, I don’t have evil superpowers, but this also ain’t my first prom.) You talk in your email about the “invention” of the paperback “just ahead of World War II” and how some writers like George Orwell didn’t like it and how they were wrong and how the current debate about e-book pricing is just like that. Leaving aside the nagging knowledge I have of yellowback novels being published way back in the 1870s and magazine serials blazing the trail for pulp fiction decades before that, let’s talk about Orwell’s fears about what paperbacks would do to what you call “literary culture.” At that time, there was no such thing as “literary fiction” or “genre fiction;” there was just “fiction,” and Orwell, who wrote dystopian sci fi with straightforward political commentary, was part of it. So were Jules Verne and H.G. Wells. So were the Bronte sisters, who wrote romance, and Sir Walter Scott, who wrote historicals, and Mark Twain, who wrote YA and comic satire, and Mary Shelley, who wrote horror. And all those books from Orwell’s era that we now consider classics too dense, boring, and “literary” for anybody but aging academics and film directors to read, like The Great Gatsby and The Sound and the Fury and Moby Dick and Ulysses, those weren’t considered “literary novels,” they were considered “novels,” and everybody who read novels read them right alongside the lighter stuff.
Paperbacks are awesome; I’ve built my life as a reader and my career as a writer on paperbacks. And they did “rejuvenat[e] the book industry and mak[e] it stronger,” in that a lot more books got published and read because they were so much cheaper, and ultimately publishers and booksellers made a lot more money. (Authors maybe not so much, but maybe so. Bigger business meant bigger demand which meant bigger paychecks for the bigger names, and more people probably got published, too.) But those bigger numbers created the need for some kind of genre categorization, at least in the minds of those publishers and booksellers, which led to the big divide between so-called “literary” fiction and “genre” fiction that plagues every author alive today and threatens to destroy any notion of a “literary culture” in English completely.
So maybe old George was on to something after all.
You (or to be fair, your spambot) also talk about how paperbacks, because of these snooty objections from the literary establishment, were first sold in drugstores and newsstands, casting Amazon as the humble newsstand/drugstore of today’s e-book world. Well . . . maybe. If we’re talking about a drugstore that first puts all the other drugstores out of business. Then sells their paperbacks at somewhat less than cost so they can sell more candy bars and condoms by luring in more customers. Then decides to just give the paperbacks away to special customers who have credit accounts with them to buy their much more expensive prescriptions, explaining to the people who make their living off the paperbacks that they’ll pay them a percentage of the nothing they’re charging, they promise. And when those people who make their living off the paperbacks object, accuses them of wanting readers to die because they’re being denied access to cheap medicine. Then, yeah, the comparison is probably pretty apt.
So in response to your request, I would like to suggest a new marketing model to you and Facebook and Google and all the other companies who hire marketing copy writers (most of whom probably wrote at least the first couple of chapters of a novel at some point) to write this kind of mass communication to me and the rest of us content providers and customers and such; sort of a new mission statement. It’s not a new concept; my grandfather was fond of it, but it has the kind of folksy charm I think you were going for here.
Stop pissing on my shoes and telling me it’s raining.
Love and kisses,
(Credit for the groovy writer girl graphic to the brilliant Isabel Samaras)
54 thoughts on “A Letter to Amazon”
Reblogged this on and commented:
My sister, and literary freedom-fighter, Lucy Blue wrote this amazing open letter to Amazon. Check it out. I promise it says what you’re thinking!
Hear, hear! But remember, the massive Amazon animal doesn’t have eyes and ears, it only has the highly evolutionary internal sensory organ The Wallet. You can get The Wallet’s attention by starving it…and…well…that’s pretty much the only way.
Oh so very right you are.
Reblogged this on fourteentooneblog.
I got the same email from Amazon. For a second I was flattered. The next second I was laughing out loud. You see, Amazon thinks we’re all stupid. There’s plenty of evidence to encourage that thought, but anyone who has put their mind to writing out a couple hundred pages on one topic can usually think for themselves.
Fox News notwithstanding.
That was exactly my reaction – I just sat there thinking, ‘they’ve gotta be kidding with this.’
Reblogged this on M.T. Miles.
Pitch perfect satire.
You’re very kind – thank you so much!
Love it. You go Norma Ray! I will also reblog from my other acct. Thank you!
Ha! Promise to think of me fondly when they walk me out of the plant in handcuffs, okay? Someone here at home said, ‘what if Amazon pulls all your books?’ I said, ‘that’s certainly their prerogative. They’re so far down in the sales rankings, though, they may have some trouble finding them.’
I will buy your books as soon as I am working, I promise. What kind of books do you write, by the way?
Reblogged this on Friendly Cove Farm and commented:
A post close to my heart. Loved it!
Thank you so much!
it is funny, people used to think Walmart is the bad guy, but Amazon has been really upsetting people lately.
That’s very true. I think part of it is that they’ve gotten so big and so successful, we’re scared of them as a reflex. But I think the pragmatically-sound-but-potentially-scary business practice of always going after bigger profits, no matter how big your profits might get, has driven them (and a lot of other formerly-beloved corporate entities) to push harder and harder to make that sale, to use every possible legal means to grab another dollar, even if all it is is legal, even if it hurts the same people they started out to serve who have put them where they are. I would like to think that if enough of us squeak out in protest, they’ll step back. But that doesn’t seem likely, does it? Like allthoughtswork pointed out above, they only listen with the Wallet.
Reblogged this on Have We Had Help? and commented:
More on the Amazon and Hatchett saga
Well written and well thought out. Thanks.
Thank you for reading.
Now my shoes and the yellow brick road I’m on are color-coordinated. Watch out for the flying monkeys, and pay no attention to that man behind the curtain… Seriously wonderful post, Lucy. Thank you.
Lol Thank you!
I was not aware that Amazon are trying to get writers on their side. I gave up ordering from them months ago, when the news broke about how they treated the people who work for them.
I have done a couple of things through Kindle Direct Publishing, which got me on their spam list. Not the smartest move they ever made. Like someone else wrote above, tweaking writers and expecting passive compliance is never smart.
it will be interesting to see how this develops. 🙂
Reblogged this on BLOGTENDI.
Thanks very much for an informative article written in a way that keeps us reading!
Thank you so much!
Reblogged this on Right, write! and commented:
Loving your work, your wit and your writing. Reblogged on my own blog, so have expanded your audience by potentially 4 😏
Hey, four more readers would thrill me no end–thank you!
Reblogged this on sherriemiranda1.
Loved this piece, so well written and I giggled when you were talking about them having lunch with no peers 🙂
Thanks so much! I love your avatar/graphic, btw.
Thanks, I love it and it fitted the tone of my blog so perfectly that I had to use it 🙂
Reblogged this on Broad Views.
Reblogged this on world of madmikel.
Superb letter. Perfectly polite. By any chance did he reply?
Oh no – I doubt he’ll ever even see it. But it made me feel better.
Utterly superbly put, Lucy. And a darn good read, too! R.
Thank you so much!
Out of spite, I never download their free books. That will show them!
Seriously, entertaining and well written.
I should disclose that I am an Amazon customer. I should also disclose the current path to literary success seems so fraught with obstacles that I don’t much care which corporate entity purports to represent my (future potential) needs.
That said, I don’t like corporations being jerks, but even then, we’re discussing nothing more than degrees of jerkiness.
You tell ’em! Right on! Power to the people and all that jazz. But seriously, you’re so right & good for you for telling them off.
Agreed on almost all counts. (And btw, I type this now on my Kindle Fire; my Norma Rae skills definitely need work. 😉 )
Reblogged this on What N Da World Is Goin On?!.
The arrogance of the Amazon corporation and Mr. Bezos in particular seems to have generated a lot of column inches, ney feet, yards…I had cause to berate the corporation and it’s workplace practice recently.Human beings, writers and artists are mere commodities in Jeff’s world. Writers may be under attack but have a care for the employees of said conglomerate as it leaves boot prints on lives.
Reblogged this on dreaming of cities and commented:
I love this and agree entirely! Though I publish through Amazon, their condescending, misquoting, factually incorrect letter inspired me to incorporate sell buttons onto my own site and prioritise the other online retailers I use like Kobo, B&N, iBooks, etc.
Amazon, writers tend not to be stupid, whether traditionally or independently published!
Reblogged this on gustdavid2315.
Reblogged this on A Day in the Life… and commented:
My love for reading, respect for the authors and artists, and working in a bookstore made me feel the need to share this. Thanks.
Reblogged this on http://elizabeth1681.wordpress.com/
Love the way you let the truth rip.